Caldwell Lost & Found Pepper Cream Soda Supreme Cream

Some cigars lay it all out on the band—perhaps none better than the Pepper Cream Soda Supreme Cream. With its lime green label and head-turning name, Pepper Cream Soda has long been a boutique favorite—and now it’s back as a regular production blend to appease the masses. Revived under Robert Caldwell’s Lost & Found project, Supreme Cream keeps the soul of the original intact while dialing in a more refined texture and balance.

Rolled in three classic formats, the Supreme Cream pairs an Ecuadorian Arapiraca wrapper with Dominican binder and fillers. The construction stays true to Lost & Found’s small-batch ethos, designed to deliver consistency across sizes while maintaining its signature flavor profile.

On the palate, the Pepper Cream Soda Supreme Cream lives up to its name, opening with bright bursts of pepper before settling into a silky wave of creaminess. Subtle cedar, soft spice, and a hint of minerality round out the profile, creating a medium-bodied experience that feels both playful and polished. For longtime fans, it’s a welcome return; for newcomers, it’s an open invitation to see why this smoke earned its cult status in the first place.